Pseudo-science: Vaastu Shastra

Dec 14 2011


A word on pseudo-sciences

Most pseudo-sciences are designed to deceive people. Smarter the people, smarter the deceivers! The proponents of pseudo-sciences devise elaborate mechanisms, terminology, and introduce new concepts which closely resemble those of real science. This ‘resemblance’ is played upon heavily.This ‘resemblance’ to science is what makes them attractive to gullible educated masses. By using astronomical objects, such as planets and stars, and using mathematical tools, such as calculations, calculators and computers, astrologers try to posit their belief systems as science. The educated people do not like to be seen as gullible people- they never want to admit to themselves or to others that they are gullible. Instead, they like to be seen as those who ‘question’, then ‘verify’, and only then ‘accept’, just like in real science. Such educated people, while growing up, study science as if it is a complicated subject, never actually question what is taught, but accept it as another dogmatic notion. To some extent, they think that Theory of Gravity and Quantum Physics is some imaginary topic concocted by some weird scientists, whom they cannot relate to. They end up not understanding the real meaning of such topics. For them scientists are too far away- unable to connect to them, while these quacks, knaves, godmen, astrologers, vaastu experts, etc, seem to connect to them so well. Just because these educated people have scored high marks in the subject called Science, they think they don’t need to learn anything new. Without actually understanding what science is and what science stands for, they enter the real world; without having developed the scientific temperament, they start representing the elite.


They spend little time in trying to ‘question’ and ‘verify’ if astrology, vaastu shastra, numerology are indeed sciences. Enter the proponents of pseudo-sciences with tools and theories constructed from false assumptions built on fantastical premises, substituting fallacious argument for logic where necessary. These gullible educated people fall for it. Actually they are believers already; they have acquired these belief systems through parents, teachers, books, TV shows, college friends, etc. At a minimum, they have resorted to ‘questioning’ as a perfunctory exercise. They ignore most of these obvious fallacies, get enamored with other 'seemingly logical' explanations, get satisfied that indeed it is science. Such educated people who become believers are the dangerous lot. They occupy high positions in the society- they are celebrities, sports players, famous actors, prominent leaders, top businessmen, elite academicians, and highly reputed professors. When such people endorse the pseudo-sciences, the believers get further boost. When such people enter the mainstream media and use these notions as accepted truths, the belief system gets further fillip. Now, it is no longer a question of being valid, it has already become the truth- it is science indeed. The argument goes- “if it was bogus, how come it is prevalent for so long and how come it is accepted by so many?”


A word on Vaastu Shastra

I didn’t know where to start. So, I start with an article that appeared in the THE HINDU in Property Plus section.
# 1. Here, S. BS. Surendran is considered a ‘specialist’ in Vaastu and Feng Shui. He is an electrical engineer who turned into a believer. When such learned people endorse it, what becomes of common man? He says, “Basically vaasthu speaks of air, ether, water, earth and cosmos”.

What is ether? Didn’t we debunk it long ago? What is cosmos? Does he mean the Universe? If so, isn’t earth, air and water already a part of it? No science can take on such elements to construct a theory. That the whole world has five elements, fire, earth, water, air, and ether, is a very old and archaic notion that has been debunked, rejected and completely relegated to myth and folklore hundreds of years ago. That it should reappear in a newly packaged form is unfortunate. It’s like studying once again that earth is flat and that it is the center of the universe, that sun is actually an angel running around in a chariot pulled by horses.
# 2. Next, this Surendran jumps into the world of science from the world of faith without making any distinction between the two. He says, “Vaasthu predominantly focuses on the flow of energy, i.e. the magnetic lines of forces existing in the earth”.

Yes, the magnetic lines are a theoretical construct to study and explain the behavior of magnetism. By borrowing an idea from science, a proponent of a pseudo-science tries to posit his belief system as science. The electromagnetic theory from real science is good enough to completely deal with all effects of magnetism, so how come we need vaastu to explain the same force once again? Most proponents resort to using the concepts from accepted sciences once in a while. This way they confuse the believers. The believers think: “we know this already from science, we cannot deny this, therefore what he says next is also undeniable.”

# 3. Talking about vaasthu, he says, “It is believed that each has a specific wavelength and field; so, adding and removing a few things ensures balance in your environment”.

Hmm... notice how he has used the terms like, ‘wavelength’ and ‘field’. Those are the words used in real sciences. Any heat generating object radiates and has a wavelength. A charge or a magnetic pole has a field around it. This is known to all who study science. But a home does not have a charge, it is grounded. We don’t speak of a man’s wavelength in science. We do that figuratively in language. Now, do homes have a specific wavelength and a field? That’s complete gobbledygook. What is balance when talking about a wavelength? Can we say, ‘Ah! Now we have attained the balance in wavelength?’

Another favorite thing these pseudo-sciences try to do is humanize the sciences.
The proponents realize that scientific theories like Theory of Gravity have no bearing on one's personal life. Gravity cannot better your scores in the exams or solve your marital problems. To bring home the science, they concoct theories which seem to have a bearing on your life- affecting your daily life, helping you in business, in exams and personal relationships. They talk about energy all the time- positive energy, negative energy, cosmic energy, balance of energy, etc. We all went to school. I ask you all one question- can energy be negative or positive? That’s complete bullshit. Energy is neither negative nor positive. It’s a scalar quantity. There’s no such thing called ‘negative’ energy in science. One can use this term for describing emotions, but that’s not science- it does not come in joules. Most of these proponents use these words interchangeably, changing the context arbitrarily- sometimes it’s the energy from the magnetic field, and next moment it’s the ‘negative’ energy surrounding a person. By using these words which are used in science and also in literary world, these proponents deceive us into believing that they are all the same. According to them, emotions is science, science is emotions.

# 4. He, then says, “There may be a sudden change in the ‘luck cycle’ of the occupants”.

Hmm, this is where it becomes completely nonsensical. You say it is science, and then you talk of ‘luck cycle’! What is ‘luck cycle’ anyway? How can luck be changed by adjusting wavelengths and fields? This is something nobody knows and nobody cares to explain. All pseudo-sciences are based on big gaps in logic which they cover up with weird new concepts, like ‘luck cycle’, ‘chakras’, etc.

# 5. He says, “The most common negative energy built up is the cluttered home.” Really? Does home’s energy go down because it is cluttered?

# 6. And it becomes more interesting. He says, “This mess is either cleaned or moved and causes a block to the free flow of energy leading to some kind of a stagnation”.

I say, “Imagine a gutter, throw some garbage in it, and see how the movement of the water gets restricted. Hmm, let’s apply the same analogy to energy as well. You see, the energy is liquid, it is flowing from one place to another, if you don’t clean your home, this flow gets restricted; it stagnates, like in the gutter”. Such wrong analogies are dangerous. People can be easily swayed into thinking that energy indeed gets obstructed by clutter and mess in the house.

# 7. He then says, “It’s sad that one looks at these sciences as a ‘first-aid-kit’”.
You know, what’s sad? That engineers like him should embrace such rubbish notions calling them science to fool people and to earn some quick money. The history is fraught with miracle men, who sell you trinkets telling you that it will get you good luck. The danger now is that even educated people are turning into miracle men who want to bring you good luck by selling you some fantastic stories as science.

# 8. Talking about Fish tanks, laughing Buddha and miniature fountains, he says, “Symbolisms and gadgets are sidetracking people”. What he means is that these 'other' frauds are taking away his business. He wants to make sure people do not get their luck sorted out by such quick-fixes. He says about them: “These commercialized items enhance negative energy if placed in wrong places”. Hmm, that’s interesting. Do they enhance ‘negative’ energy because they are commercialized items, or because they are in the wrong places? Make up your mind!

Before the reader goes away, he wants to make sure you take his expert advice (which always includes some kind of remuneration and reward for him): “I carried corrections by just re-orienting furniture and cots”. If it is indeed science, shouldn’t we all be in a position to buy a book, study it, calculate the amount of ‘negative energy’ our home offers, and then add ‘positive energy’ item to strike a balance? We should be able to put our map of the house into an open-source software, and get the results! None of the pseudo-sciences offer such packages. They all want you to consult an expert. All these proponents profess to be experts, look down upon and talk down upon ‘other’ experts, dismiss them as knaves, and tell you that it is something like a rocket-science-complicated-complex-equation-oriented-art-craft-science that only he can solve and make it right for you. That’s when you should wake up and walk off.

# 9. Talking about wind chimes, he says: “In all our religious practices too, sound energy is used to cleanse the space, invoke positive feelings and disperse negativity”.

In our ‘religious practices’? I thought you were discussing science here. When did we change the topic to religion? Oh, I forgot, all you quacks mix religion, faith, belief, superstition, and position it as science, right? Imagine sound energy cleansing the space. So, I guess, I can play music at extremely loud volume and clean up the entire space, and kick out the ‘negative energy’ for good!

And hey, how come you started talking about positive ‘feelings’ now? I though you were talking about positive ‘energies’. Oh, never mind! You guys interchange these words at your whim-and-fancy to suit your purpose. Feelings=energies! Great! To increase the potential energy of a rocket, one just has to put lot of good ‘feelings’ into it. Lo and behold! It is now flying away into the space powered by the ‘feelings’ of the entire nation! Not a drop of rocket fuel needed anymore. From
tomorrow, I want to ride my scooter on my feelings- I don’t have to spend money on petrol!

# 10. And now for the finale! He says, “We in India have a mindset to be skeptical about our own faiths and beliefs”.

I on the other hand think that we are better off being skeptical. What we need is an overdose of that skepticism towards our faiths, beliefs, and superstitions, not the renewed faith in such arcane belief systems. We need to embrace science, question superstition, and bring in rational thought. I am happy to know that he thinks that we are being skeptical. But coming from him, who has been selling me a completely cooked up and fantastic story, I don’t believe this either!
Vaastu is another of those hobbies that is being touted as alternate science. Such belief-oriented pseudo-sciences curb creativity by imposing not-so-well-understood rules, bringing in occultism back into our lives. Such methods are based on how one man's interpretation is better than the other without allowing the common man to make an independent verification.

The author is an active blogger, entrepreneur, founder and CEO of Sloka Telecom, a radio access network solution provider.
He blogs at http://sujaiblog.blogspot.com

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

My web-site :: Pauline

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Feel free to surf to my webpage - Bev

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Other solutions consist of DOT examinations, health partners plans
employee benefits (Loren) danger evaluations, alcohol and drug
screening and EKG Management.

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

my webpage - Sam

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

What a stuff of un-ambiguity and preserveness of valuable know-how concerning unexpected emotions.

Also visit my website :: website design north bay graphic design north bay

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Another major difference between the two is that while PPC is a paid form of advertising, organic search engine
optimization is absolutely free. The process of SEO is the series of steps that are undertaken to ensure that a website (Leandra) is
visible among internet users to an optimal level.
Unlike TV, radio and other traditional marketing
channels that need big budgets to be effective, SEO
can be cost effective. Webmaster follows a long process to promote
a website in top search engines (Google, Yahoo and Bing).

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

It's very straightforward to find out any topic on net as compared to textbooks, as I found this piece
of writing at this web site.

Feel free to visit my web blog; afdas marseille

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

The value of providing excellent material isn't really merely influencing
organic Search Engine Optimization - same adjustments are occurring on social media and Facebook.

Also visit my webpage best dallas seo - Dianna -

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

my web site; losing weight (http://www.haiyijiao.com/)

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Another major difference between the two is that while PPC is a paid form of
advertising, organic search engine optimization is absolutely free.
Two: Research different services - Assuming that you are going
to hire someone to do it for you, the next step is to research as many different
services as possible. I am hoping to show you that I can help you
achieve top rankings in the sites like I have for all my other
clients. Eventbrite is an online party-planning tool with KISS (Keep It
Simple Stupid) design so it is usually a top rated choice among event planners (organizers).

Stop by my weblog ... HVAC Frederick MD

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

It also contributes to reflux symptoms by flushing overfull stomach contents up into your esophagus.

Muscles and neurons are activated by electrolyte activity.
Choose one thing that you are going to do that will help
you reduce your sugar intake.

Stop by my website :: nucifc bio x4 review

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Also visit my weblog; venus factor - Roma,

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

hi!,I like your writing so so much! proportion we keep in touch more about your post on AOL?

I need an expert in this space to unravel my problem.
Maybe that's you! Looking ahead to look you.

Look at my web site :: garcinia cambogia elite free trial canada

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Inspiring quest there. What happened after? Thanks!

Look into my weblog :: decorating

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Everyone loves it when individuals get together and share opinions.
Great website, continue the good work!

My web-site latest telugu movie reviews

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Usually I don't read article on blogs, but I would like to say that this write-up very compelled me to take a look at and do it!

Your writing taste has been surprised me. Thank you, very nice post.

Also visit my site; Neudermis Skincare

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

My family members always say that I am killing my time here at net, except I know I am getting experience daily by reading thes good articles.

Here is my site ... Rejuvalux Review

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Combination with the Apple's allied health advocates
llc seattle [Nida] app could
be much better, though: currently, it just
shares step-tracking and sleep-analysis information.

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Gone are the days of one way marketing or merely just posting comments about
your site or other related topics. The usual SEO methods include keyword research, link building and
such. Unlike TV, radio and other traditional marketing channels that need big budgets to be effective, SEO can be cost effective.
You have to take price quotes from different SEO companies locally and internationally.

My page - web page (Emily)

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Here is my weblog :: Bruce

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Feel free to visit my web page: venus factor review (Hassan)

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Crackers with toppings can make great treats for the everyday
diet and for special events.

Feel free to surf to my site: health insurance marketplace customer service
number (Shawn)

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Also visit my site - Callum

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Hey There. I found your weblog the usage of msn. This is
a really smartly written article. I will be sure to bookmark
it and come back to read more of your useful information. Thank you for the post.
I will certainly comeback.

my blog ... perfect biotics

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

According to the National health partners plans of philadelphia Interview Study, 75 % of
the population struggles with stress in every two weeks.

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

2014 teemed with huge updates to neighborhood
search results, as well as it is unidentified what type
of modifications 2015 will bring.

Feel free to surf to my site :: dallas texas seo (Grady)

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Visit my web site: Monte

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Camp Eden health administration jobs california (Homer) Resort is more than a location - it's a frame of mind and a way of life.

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Feel free to visit my website diets [Kathaleen]

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

As soon as you have identified the sort of renovation you want
to do consider your spending plan.

My web blog :: septic system

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Hi, the whole thing is going perfectly here and ofcourse every one is
sharing information, that's truly good, keep up writing.

Also visit my blog post ... Alvena Cream

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Amazing blog! Is your theme custom made or did you download it from somewhere?

A design like yours with a few simple adjustements would really make my blog shine.
Please let me know where you got your theme. Thanks a lot

Feel free to visit my blog :: autoelectricianessex.co.uk

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Excellent blog here! Also your site loads up very fast!
What web host are you using? Can I get your affiliate
link to your host? I wish my web site loaded up as fast as yours lol

Also visit my site :: real ways to make your dick bigger - http://hytest.hit.edu.cn/ -

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

What's up everyone, it's my first pay a quick visit at this site, and paragraph is actually fruitful in support of me, keep up posting these types of
content.

my webpage: pure garcinia cambogia dr oz free trial
- Annis,

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

You actually make it seem so easy with your presentation but
I find this topic to be really something that I think I
would never understand. It seems too complex and
very broad for me. I'm looking forward for your next post, I'll try to get the hang of it!

Feel free to visit my site ... Felix

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

SEO intending needed to obtain a lot more creative as well as employ even more paid and also non-paid explanation to assist material
reach larger audiences.

Look into my web page ... dallas texas seo (Hwa)

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Rebounding on an individual mini trampoline is an alternative health administration jobs california strategy
for getting rid of contaminants.

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

I really love your blog.. Great colors & theme. Did you build this web site
yourself? Please reply back as I'm trying to create my own personal
blog and would like to find out where you got
this from or just what the theme is called. Thanks!

My web-site Brandon Colker

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Your home is valueble for me. Thanks!

Feel free to visit my web page: marvel contest of champions hack ios - Angelina -

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Fantastic beat ! I would like to apprentice whilst you amend your site, how could i subscribe for a blog site?

The account helped me a applicable deal. I have been tiny bit acquainted of this your
broadcast offered vivid clear idea

My site ... perfect biotics reviews

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

My web site Andres

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Spot on with this write-up, I really believe this website needs
a great deal more attention. I'll probably be back again to see more, thanks for the info!

My web-site perfect biotics

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Awesome! Its truly remarkable paragraph, I have got much clear
idea concerning from this piece of writing.

My webpage :: amazon top selling skincare

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

You simply have to enter the measurements of your
washroom, choose the products, and also you get home renovation ideas on a budget near-accurate price of restoration for your restroom.

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Although being aware of keyword percentages is a good idea, it is more important that content be relevant
and useful to the visitor. Thirdly, the search engines need
legit companies to do site optimization. Unlike
TV, radio and other traditional marketing channels that need big
budgets to be effective, SEO can be cost effective. Further the sites whose ranking using
the search engines is good will attract potential clients, which results to mores sales.

Here is my blog ... HVAC Frederick MD

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

My programmer is trying to convince me to move to .net from PHP.
I have always disliked the idea because of the expenses.

But he's tryiong none the less. I've been using WordPress on numerous
websites for about a year and am nervous about switching to another platform.
I have heard very good things about blogengine.net. Is there a way I can import all my wordpress
content into it? Any help would be greatly appreciated!

Feel free to visit my page: Ian Leaf Tax

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Statutory guidelines in Texas presume that an obligor who pays kid computer
support; Lashunda, has optimal
net resources in the amount of not more than $6,000.

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

Hey just wanted to give you a quick heads up.
The words in your content seem to be running off the screen in Ie.
I'm not sure if this is a format issue or something to do
with internet browser compatibility but I figured I'd post to let you know.
The design look great though! Hope you get the problem
solved soon. Thanks

Here is my page - Carpet Cleaning birmingham al

Reply to comment | The Tripura Foundation

I’m not that much of a internet reader to be honest but your blogs really nice, keep it
up! I'll go ahead and bookmark your site to come back later on. Many thanks

Feel free to visit my page: perfect biotics reviews